Benromach 10 years old
Strength: 40% ABV
Additional: 9 years in a mix of sherry (1/5) and bourbon casks (4/5) before a final year combined in a sherry cask
Colour: a sandy beach
Nose: a wave of vanilla arrives before mixing it up with ginger snaps, freshly baked meringue and characteristic layers of fruit loaf. There is a slight smoky underpinning element here, perhaps that’s just my senses but a sprinkling of all-spice for sure. A playful, if limited nose.
Taste: a handful of barley just like you’ll be offered on a distillery tour, more wood and upping the vanilla factor. The sherry influence is subtle providing more ginger and the spicy notes that continue from the nose.
A solid enough dram, if I was being critical then an extended period of maturation, a slightly higher strength or more sherry emphasis can only enhance the experience. This sentiment takes us nicely onto the next sample.
Benromach 100 Proof
Age: 10 years old
Strength: 57% ABV
Additional: non-chill filtered
Colour: fresh apple juice
Nose: ah, the restrained sweetness of dried oranges, freshly cracked black pepper, homemade tablet, cinnamon and its taking me back to mulled wine. More ginger and cardamom pods with that smoky edge returning once again.
Taste: that smokes moves into the dram adding depth, the sweetness and stickiness of treacle tart with buttery pastry. All those spices once more reprising their roles, dark chocolate, coconut, vanilla fudge and heather honey all combine.
This offers more bang-for-your-buck than the staple 10 year old. A little water does add a new dimension and it leaves the traditional decade cousin standing still as it rampages ahead on all fronts.
Age: not stated but new oak casks used hence the influence below
Strength: 43% ABV
Additional: the 1st certified organic malt whisky by the Soil Association
Colour: toasted almonds
Nose: more orchard meadow than we’ve seen in anything previously from Benromach. The freshness of elderflower, pineapple, apple peel melting into apple strudel. Tree resin of all things with that sticky quality as well rounding off with crushed nuts.
Taste: a strong wood influence here with almonds, polished oak, caramel and buttered toast explaining the oily characteristic. A little marmalade tangy influence and again that touch of smoke that seems to persist with Benromach.
A solid if unspectacular dram. I’m always intrigued by the organic slant having recently tasted the Springbank ‘Green’ release that was similar in many respects – inoffensive but lacking the real complexity you’d like to see in a dram. Perhaps this all goes back to the high yield barley strains distilleries use nowadays, the movement away from coal fired stills and worm tubs. So far based on my experiences these organic examples just lack that extra dimension – given time an experimentation they’ll achieve more in the coming years.
Benromach Peat Smoke
Age: distilled 2005, bottled 2014
Strength: 46% ABV
Additional: peated malt at 35ppm from what I read elsewhere although during the tasting 67ppm was quoted. Produced in small batches.
Colour: undercooked pancakes
Nose: before Islay dominated the peat landscape, malts from the mainland were traditionally peated and this example shows why. Initially its Jakemans’ menthol sweets and Pledge furniture polish but the fizz is taking me back to old fashioned lemonade and of course peat; a real vibrant freshness.
Taste: not the huge hit of peat and being honest as always it’s all over rather too quickly on the palate. Another attempt if you don’t mind. Now we’re more attuned a rather gentle peat experience. Melted butter, highland heather, a little saltiness although I should actually say Hebridean sea salt peat smoked – a lovely product if you can track it down. Limited again, lacking the complexity of some Islay examples say Caol Ila but there’s a place for this peated experience. A nice initial foray for someone just commencing their first steps into the peated bog experience.
In summary, Benromach might be a small distillery but it is producing some solid and at later ages spectacular whiskies. Apart from the whisky experience itself the refreshing aspects overall are the pricing, openness with details about the ages, cask ratios etc. and attention to detail.