Christmas means many things from gift guides such as this example from Juliette Hearsay or to the traditional ‘best of’ line-up. In reality the latter is also just another promotional tool to persuade you to splash out on that something special. Yet there is another festive event that registers on the whisky scale and this is the epic outturn from the Scotch Malt Whisky Society.
There were some bottles missing in action including 30.87, 53.232, 82.20, G7.7, 10.85 for the preview. The lack of a grain example was lamented on our table as we’d like to see the SMWS bottle more of these on a regular basis. The Bunnahabhain was also regrettably elsewhere although there was more than enough to consider. So moving on, I’ll summarise some of the hits and misses here before a couple of more detailed reviews.
B3.2 (Rock Town) Ooey-gooey Cinnamon Bun
3 year old, 55.3%, new charred oak, 204 bottles, £59.00
A rose tint to this bourbon which I was attracted towards after the excellent B3.1 debut last year. A perfect Christmas dram with seasonal spices including cinnamon and also rhubarb on the nose. Taste wise amazingly rounded and refined for such a young age. Another winner from this distillery.
1.198 (Glenfarclas) Night Nurse in Carpenter’s Overalls
21 year old, 55.2%, refill ex-bourbon hogshead, 176 bottles, £82.10
The Society has bottled some cracking bourbons from this distillery in recent months including 1.188 and 1.194 so I was very interested in checking out another well aged Glenfarclas. Not hugely blown away by this one with a peachy colour and memories of rolled cigars and marzipan.
3.249 (Bowmore) Barnacles and Bath Bombs
14 year old, 56.4%, refill ex-bourbon hoghead, 252 bottles, exclusive to offers with 46.35 Party Pair £119
Another that prompted much debate, as initially it received a thumbs up before we returned later to experience disappointment. A very interesting Bowmore from the fact its just odd. Memories of tundra, Highland scrub and floral notes. Overshadowed by the other Bowmore which is covered in a more detailed review further down.
13.47 (Dalmore) It’s a Knockout
10 year old, 59.3%, refill ex-bourbon barrel, 199 bottles, £51.70
Really crystal clear presentation in the glass which you just don’t see from Dalmore given its love of tanning products. This naked expression offered lots of vanilla, floral notes with a real zesty feel and pronounced coffee beans. The palate delivered a real freshness and easily drinkable at cask strength. A nice starter dram.
29.173 (Laphroaig) Forget Time and Space
16 year old, 59.8%, refill ex-bourbon barrel, 250 bottles, £73.70
A real Harvey Nic’s frontage with this Islay expression. Offering everything up front but stepping beyond this it was cavernous void before reviving itself for the finish. I’d pass.
41.68 (Dailuaine) Liquified Bounty Bars
11 year old, 61.6%, 1st fill ex-bourbon barrel, 215 bottles, £50.20
Winner of the most evocative name of the night. We were all attracted to this but left wondering what delights Bounty Bars blended offered instead, as it failed to live up to such a dynamic billing.
53.231 (Caol Ila) Eat Until I Die
19 year old, 59.3%, refill ex-bourbon hogshead, 245 bottles, £89.70
Again like the Laphroaig above ticks the peat boxes for fans of this brand but does nothing to stand out from the crowd; not great or bad; just existing.
50.71 (Bladnoch) Alfresco Brunch
25 year old, 58.2%, refill ex-bourbon barrel, 165 bottles, £137.50
At the more expensive end of the tasting was this Bladnoch but what a superb example of the Lowland distillery. Rich on fruits and sweets; it felt as if I was trapped in the Willy Wonka factory. A treat but justified.
63.33 (Glentauchers) Rich, Treacly and Sumptuous
9 year old, 61.6%, 2nd fill ex-sherry butt, 661 bottles, £48.80
A real hit amongst our cluster and one of the younger drams on offer (which there were a few of) that hit home. A real sweetie.
66.76 (Ardmore) Guilty Pleasure
10 year old, 61.0%, 1st fill ex-white wine hogshead, 274 bottles, £47.00
I bought two bottles of this so that should tell you all you need to know. Amazing aromas of bacon crisps and beef dripping; it felt as if I was swimming through a sea of fatty deposits. On the palate its a real startling experiment thanks to Ardmore’s characteristics and the cask. Robust beef stew, red meats and maple syrup at play here. One of the star drams but really divided opinion.
96.8 (GlenDronach) Relaxing in an Alpine Meadow
9 year old, 58.3%, refill ex-bourbon barrel, 172 bottles, £44.20
This one immediately jumped out from the SMWS line-up as its only the 8th release from this distillery they’ve managed to bottle. Unfortunately not a sherry cask, but given the success and pleasure the Society Glenfarclas releases have provided, an early destination. Bizarre in reality, perhaps bottled too young? I was disappointed hugely by this and put it down to my personal tastes. Speaking with others it was highlighted as one to avoid. Glad to have experienced a rare example but not on my shopping list.
Snapshot impressions sorted, lets move onto 2 detailed nosing reviews from the comfort of my own home:
3.251 (Bowmore) Engineer’s Work-bench in a Boatyard
17 year old, 55.4%, refill ex-sherry butt, 553 bottles, £75.60
Nose: really pungent from a distance! Sea shore, melted caramel, icing sugar, plum jam, candied oranges, a well worn rubber band, crushed hazelnuts, pork scratching, fruit toast and ham hock.
Taste: superb symmetry between the peat and sherry butt with neither winning out in the contest. Earthy, autumn leaves, a touch of the kiln smoke, blackberries, cinnamon and cloves. Nothing explosive but thoroughly enjoyable.
37.67 (Cragganmore) Tongue Tingling Treasure
29 year old, 57.6%, refill ex-bourbon hogshead, 127 bottles, £144.20
Colour: golden barley
Nose: a forest walk with pine cones descending all around, vanilla, decaying bark and heather. Cotton sheets drying on a blisteringly hot summer’s day. Opening a long sealed pine chest to reveal old books and documents within. An evocative aroma-filled experience.
Taste: more of the fresh wood feel carried on from the nose, a vanilla ice cream float with lemonade. Flashes of sherbet and sweet peanuts, my home-made granola with walnuts, almonds, honey, cranberries and jumbo oats. Delicious.
These two were along with the Ardmore the highlights of the evening. A relaxed atmosphere amongst friends new and old, a welcome assortment of small bites and the freedom to explore, rounded off a memorable and engaging evening. Roll on next year!