A word of warning as I’ll be looking to review some American whiskies in the coming weeks. Yes, I can already hear the collective groan rebounding across the hemisphere including the theatrical repulsion from our resident bourbon enthusiast, Adam.

These forays of mine into North America never tend to go well whatsoever. Partially because what bourbons or such like we have access to here in the United Kingdom – well that’s a joke currently as we’re far from united – are the equivalent of butt sweat. I reckon that’s what Alexandra would describe it as anyway, in her inimitable style, with the dregs shipped off to the UK. Basically, the stuff even the Americans wouldn’t drink is packaged up and sent over; thanks guys!

Thing being, I want to discover the great bourbons and experiences away from the caramel and vanilla dominance. I know they exist somewhere, but living in Scotland they remain firmly out of reach. That is, until I had guests staying over from California in the Château Rover. A go-to whiskey for Rose and John is the Four Roses single barrel. This was one of several bottles they generously brought across for me to experience and form a new appreciation of all things bourbon. This particular bottle was picked out by Rose with the virtual assistance of Tony, who we’ll come to later.

I’m humbled by such gifts and new experiences. The real joy was spending time with such a great couple; showing them my small part of Scotland and the hardship of whisky being everywhere! The fact that we met virtually over whiskies and then the allure of Scotland pulled them 5000 miles east is remarkable. Whisky tourism is huge in Scotland and given how proud we are of our wee nation and the warm welcome, I suspect they’ll return again as many do.

Whenever I visit the States, I do make a point of trying to exist on whiskies and attempt to uncover new delights. It can be a real chore and eventually, my palate does become saturated with such flavours enhanced by their fake bacon and shallow beers. After a week or so, I run back into the comforting and superior embrace of all things Scotch.

Armed with this bottle I ran to the bourbon devil (aka Tony) and asked what should I cover when drafting this Four Roses review…

Tony: vanilla?

Malt: Yes, that’s a given, but what beyond the vanilla wall?

Tony: You have the 100-proof version?

Malt dispatches photo of said bottle to prove we have good bourbon for once.

Tony: Four Roses has 2 mashbills and 5 yeast strains. The 100-proof single barrel as you have is always the B mash bill (60% corn, 35% rye and 5% malted barley) and V yeast means the yeast is delicate fruit, spicy and creamy.

Really high rye content with that mash bill. I would see if you get the flavors they describe or not?

Malt: It’ll be the 5% malted barley that’s holding it together? How consistent are the single barrels? Do people seek out their favourite mash and yeast?

Tony: I’ve only had that one a few times, but I remember it being a very solid representation of the brand. I usually have the cask strength version which can be any of the 10 combinations. We were blinded at the distillery last year with 6 samples and the very first one was very familiar. I guess that it was the OBSF. And was right, so it was typical of that recipe or consistent. Yes, some people swear by certain recipes but have been blinded and picked their least favourite, or so they thought was their least favourite.

I think it also varies by year or season. Some years may have been really good F yeasts or V yeasts and the next year everyone loves the O’s or K’s.

The 5-10% malted barley in bourbon is to help breakdown the starches in bourbon. Some use commercial enzymes instead. The rye grain is a really hard grain to breakdown especially.

Their rickhouses are only one storey high to try to achieve consistent aging and use the different recipes for different profiles rather than other distilleries with one recipe making different products with barrels from different parts of their rickhouse that age differently.

Malt: If someone enjoys the Four Roses single barrel are there any other similar bourbons out there?

Tony: Old Grand Dad bottled in bond, 100-proof, high rye (27%) which brings out spice, and quite a bit cheaper, but probably a bit younger than Four Roses and not single barrel. Although I think they aim for a certain profile with the Four Roses and barrels that don’t fit that profile are blended into other products. So, I don’t think the single barrel factor comes into play much.

Armed with this knowledge from the fountain of Tony’s expertise it is now time for the actual bourbon review.

Four Roses Single Barrel – review

Colour: Peanut brittle.

On the nose: A creamy vanilla arrival with wet fabric, corn and rich caramel. A touch of orange zest, milk chocolate, ginger ale and bashed copper pans. Resin, more vanilla! A Crunchie Bar i.e. honeycomb. Small hints of raspberry or cherry? Also freshly chopped sweet potato and peeled brown onion skin. Water reveals pencil shavings.

In the mouth: Not as detailed as the nose with more toffee and syrup. Hazelnuts, rusty nails before it goes flat midway. The root vegetables give body as does a dirty v-a-n-i-l-l-a alongside woody notes and a tad too smooth for me. The addition of water showcases more sweetness in brown sugar followed by cloves, vanilla and nutmeg.


A very easy drinking and enjoyable above average bourbon. I’d have preferred a bit more guts with a higher strength, but there is something here for everyone. Be gentle with water, as it is a fragile thing. A staple for every Scotch cupboard that is looking for a bit of vanilla bourbon action, especially if you’re unable to pick up a bottle of the legendary Plainsman.

Score: 6/10

  1. Tony says:

    I don’t remember my spelling being that funny, but nice review. Glad to see that you, as well as Rose and John, enjoy it.

    1. Jason says:

      Hi, CS. Not at all. Adding a dash of water releases oils and natural compounds. Always worth trying especially when you have a bottle to play with.

  2. NOTNICE_75 says:

    “It can be a real chore and eventually, my palate does become saturated with such flavours enhanced by their fake bacon and shallow beers. After a week or so, I run back into the comforting and superior embrace of all things Scotch.”

    Jason, I’m 100% with you re. “fake bacon”, and even after living in the US for nearly twenty years now, I’ve never acquired much of a taste for bourbon. However, I think your characterization of American beer as “shallow” is a long way off the mark. Perhaps you are aiming for an easy target – the Bud Lites and Old Milwaukees and etc. – but I can assure you that the brewing scene on this side of the Atlantic is leagues ahead of what’s happening in the UK. Essentially, the American craft brewers took the old beer styles that we Brits had more or less abandoned in favour of cheap lagers and industrial bitter, and reinvigorated the recipes – not always with a great deal of subtlety, but certainly with enthusiasm and plenty of additional ABVs. Oh, and I’ll tell you what…one thing that bourbon is definitely good for: barrel aging your average super-fudgy, double-decadent 10%+ imperial stouts!

    Anyway, not necessarily whisky related…but worth making a point, I think.

    1. Jason says:

      Hi NN75, that was a bit of sarcasm, I’ll stick it in italics which might help. I’ve had a few beers from Sonoma recently, very good, although there are some exciting small scale Scottish brewers appearing now. Cheers!

  3. Welsh Toro says:

    I like this one and I always have a bottle on the shelf. I get it from a Spanish wine exporter and it costs less than £30 so it’s a good deal. There are days when I’m just not in the mood for Scotch and my body and palate needs something else and some of the sweet stuff hits the mark. I completely agree that you can have too much of a good thing when it comes to bourbon or rye and tasting notes are the same words in different order. However, there’s good and bad and Four Roses Single Barrel is pretty good.

  4. Thomas B Cohoon says:

    I’m an American but a dominant Scotch drinker. Here in America there are some delicious Single Malts appearing from Balcones, Virginia Distillery and others. As far as Bourbon I am not much of a fan. The Four Roses Single Barrel is the one bourbon that I like. I believe it does require a little water to “open up”, but not too much or it does fall apart. The finish is just glorious and the nose eventful. One of few bourbons that give a decent Scotch like journey from an interesting nose to a transformative palette and a good finish.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *