C

Cadenhead’s Aultmore 2006

Yeah, ok, it’s an Aultmore, but please stay with me and read on; I promise it’ll be worth it for a change.

In a nutshell, this is the issue with Aultmore. It exists and has benefited from the single malt boom with a range exclusively of its own making. Bacardi have thrown huge sums of money at various distilleries within their portfolio, to relatively little success. Do you remember the fanfare? The lavish designs and brand ambassadors trying to win us over. The love that we were meant to feel for the distillery and the rest of the Last Great Malts series that included Aberfeldy, Craigellachie and Deveron?

Frankly, it hasn’t happened now has it? Being the reasonable person that I am, the whisky is ok, if a little overpriced. In reality, it should be better presented with a higher strength and revisiting those price points. With so much variety and choice nowadays, consumers will tend to head towards something they either trust, or is seemingly perceived as value. Neither of these elements feature within the planning of the Last Great Malts series.

We all make mistakes in life and anyone that tells you they otherwise is lying and likely works for Macallan. I applaud Bacardi for the effort to bring a little of the spotlight to these distilleries, however, let’s face facts – the public really don’t care. Along with the 2 aforementioned factors they are creatures of habit. This applies to what they aspire to be seen drinking or lingering around. Aultmore, Royal Brackla and their ilk just don’t cut the mustard when it comes to something to aspire to. In reality, this is something that distilleries across Scotland are in the process of finding out. A few out there have ideas above their station and fantasies of grandeur. They’ve all jumped on the limited and premium bandwagon in the hope of hitting that gold rush. Even Glen Moray – one of Mark’s favourite distilleries – attempted such a feat with the Mastery. With a price tag of £800 for a bottle from a distillery that sits proudly in the value end of the supermarket.

The premium thing as Mortlach and Longmorn showed, may seem a great concept in the boardroom and marketing meetings. Transferring that into the real world isn’t simply achieved with a release, or a high price tag. The public need to desire and sweat a little about a pending release. Hang around a whisky shop for an hour and ask the punters which distilleries would they aspire to purchase a new release from (regardless of price) and I bet you my open bottle of Jura Journey, they won’t mention Aultmore, Glen Moray etc.

To reach that status takes time. New distilleries dropping releases for 3 figure sums and 50cl bottles need to be sent home to think again. You have to put the effort and graft into it. Take our Irish soil chums at Waterford. They could launch some bespoke farm whisky encased in farmer Ted’s soiled wellington boot, which in turn is wrapped in a hand polished piece of French oak – but would it sell as a premium product? No, because a new brand or a distillery in this case, needs to work to reach the summit.

Back to the Last Great Malts range and specifically Craigellachie, where in 2018, Bacardi announced a 51-year-old whisky that you could try for free in various locations. I’m sure this sparked some nappy changes amongst the influencers and Instagramers. From my viewpoint, I thought it was a total misstep and smacked of desperation. It panders to the worst elements of today’s society. The instant gratification and focus around an age statement. Overlooked was the fact that at a strength of 40.3%, something had to be done with this cask so why not send out a brand ambassador across the world to pour it away free? Nice gig if you can get it, I’m sure. Yeah, it may have attracted the odd post and article online, but in today’s instant gratification world of whisky, the influencers and their ilk have the attention span as changeable as the Scottish weather. Today’s post is history the very next day.

And consider the fact that if you’ve had a 51-year-old whisky from a distillery for free, would this encourage you to drop down into the core range and explore what lies beneath? Imagine taking out that McLaren for a test drive and upon your return being offered a shot in a Ford Fiesta? Would that set your heart racing or perk up any interest? Exactly, once you’ve reached that summit, the only way is down. The fact that most of the Last Great Malts range are gathering dust across the country and are focusing on the travel retail sector, confirms it’s another entry in the growing book of disappointing launches.

In saying all of this, I did want to talk about what makes Aultmore an interesting whisky and distillery. It can deliver given the right presentation and circumstances, but we’ll go into that in more detail another time as I promise to review another before the year is out. I’m guilty of not seeking out Aultmore in recent times and this whole article only came around when I won a 10cl sample of this release at a Cadenhead’s Edinburgh lucky dip. Insert comment here about how even the independents cannot give it away.

Upon unwrapping the package, I will admit there was some disappointment. An Aultmore isn’t something to get excited about and a 12-year-old matured in an ex-bourbon hogshead isn’t an attractive tune to the whisky public. The official 12 is ok and borderline priced at £44.95 but a little flawed. This Cadenhead’s was distilled in 2006 and bottled in July 2019, it is un-coloured and unchill filtered giving us a sense of what the official Aultmore 12-year-old should be capable of at 56.4%. Priced circa £50, Cadenhead’s have also bottled a sister cask I believe with a similar strength of 56.6%, both bottled as part of the Authentic Collection – so do consult the label – and there was a Small Batch release recently at 57.4% if you want to up the confusion stakes.

Cadenhead’s Aultmore 2006 – review

Colour: lime juice.

On the nose: sappy with some new make reflux residue. Green apples, melon, grapefruit, sawdust and fennel. White pepper follows with silver needle tea, a flowered bap and Fenugreek seeds. Chocolate mint leaf, limes and Agave take us on some trip. Water reveals olives, jelly sweeties, coconut water and a gentle cinnamon.

In the mouth: oily and an impressive texture with a rich viscosity. My attention has been snared. More green apples, white chocolate, used tea leaves, aniseed and grapefruit. Chalky towards the finish with liquorice root and Kiwi fruit. Water showcases more oiliness and tartness thereby amplifying all of the above. Pine needles and bashed limes round off this Aultmore.

Conclusions

My personal in-joke at the recent Cadenhead’s tasting was that I paid £25 for a ticket to try the 3 whiskies I had previously pre-ordered. This access confirmed that I would have been disappointed by all 3 purchases. I promptly cancelled them all the following week. By spending £25, I had actually saved circa £150. Proving the wisdom of trying before you buy.

The bonus was this lucky dip Aultmore. If this had been featured within the tasting line-up, I would have only put it 2nd to the 24-year-old Springbank that evening. It has character in abundance without the requirement of a finish. There is much to discover and appreciate here although I would underline this isn’t a beginner whisky.

This is fairly close to the official 12-year-old in terms of price. Frankly, it resides in another taste dimension and the lack of colour may dissaude initial enquiries. Ditch this favouritism of colour and let your senses guide you. A lovely surprise.

Score: 7/10

CategoriesSingle Malt
Jason
Jason

JJ is based in Scotland, which means he’s able to reach out and enjoy a wealth of distillery trips and whiskies. Although, it’s more than likely you’ll find him in the Edinburgh Cadenhead's shop or in front of a laptop.

  1. Avatar
    Andrew says:

    I’ve been following Malt for a little while now and I do find the heavy opinion in the reviews refreshing, even when I think it’s opposed to my own reviews, the sheer disdain at times is excellent.

    I really enjoyed the standard bottling of the 12yr old when I had one although I’ll admit my experience isn’t as expansive so it’s possible that I didn’t have the frame of reference that you do. I’d love to try this.

    I’ve only managed to get into a Cadenhead’s shop once on a special birthday trip to London and picked up a highly excellent random bottling of Single Cask Teaninich 11yr old that was destined for the Polish market (or so I was told). I bought it blind and it blew my socks off, I shed a real tear when I finished it three years later.

    Having a Cadenhead’s “just down the road” would probably be the best and worst thing in the world ever.

    1. Jason
      Jason says:

      Hi Andrew

      Thanks for dropping by. It’s good to hear you don’t agree with everything here – I’d be worried if you did. Even I don’t agree with some of the team either but we accept our views and move on. Sadly, not everything online seems able to do this. Celebrate differences and don’t wallow in the mire, or Jura.

      I’d like to think we have more balance here. Too many websites or in demand whisky consultants are basically kissing ass on a chronic nature. Whisky isn’t cheap and neither is the cost of living. We appreciate those values and our independence.

      I’ve still got the official 12yo at home as well. I return to it now and again. It’s solid but this more natural presentation is another league and I do enjoy the odd Teaninch – a distillery we need to cover more here.

      Sadly these days with Cadenhead’s, everyone is trying to get a certain whisky. The days are gone where you can have your pick or even second choice. I sometimes wonder who is buying all this stuff and for what purpose? I hope this month’s outturn is better than July.

      Cheers, Jason.

  2. Avatar
    Welsh Toro says:

    A well thought out review. Bacardi jumped on the bandwagon but, as you correctly observe, it’s flopped. Big chunky bottles could not disguise the fact that a 12 year whisky bottled at 40% cost over £45. A total joke. The 16 year costs more than £80 and it’s still 40%. I think some arse or team of arses thought they could take on Macallan! I felt the Aultmore was better. The 12 is bottled at 46% and has a far superior price/quality ratio. I picked up the 18 in an airport a few years ago for about £90 and thoroughly enjoyed it. A big step up in quality and a fine ex-bourbon expression. It’s only ever been available in travel retail or a certain French retailer we all know. The price has crept up and it is now a ridiculous £130. Not worth it anymore. The lost me as a customer. The prices of the older expressions are simply insane.

    In the mean time I’ve been hunting older independent Aultmore, 20 years or so in ex-bourbon with great success. There are some real gems out there that are far cheaper and superior to the distillery offerings. I think Aultmore is, in fact, a very good distillery and I’m not surprised that it’s valued by the blenders. Bacardi have done a total Mortlach with Royal Brackla. They can sell some Aultmore 12 but hardly anyone will buy the rest. It’s a total failure of marketing strategy as far as I can see for all the reasons you describe. Nevertheless, I’d encourage some further dabbling into the indi Aultmore. Cheers Jason. WT

    1. Jason
      Jason says:

      Evening WT

      You’ll be pleased to know we have another indie Aultmore review incoming and also one from Royal Brackla. There is sadly a great deal of greed and chasing of the luxury market. I’d rather exist in the doldrums of whisky, where the soul of the spirit hasn’t sold itself to the highest bidder. I’m sure I won’t be alone down there, or unhappy.

      Thanks, Jason.

Leave a Reply to Welsh Toro Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *